The Hidden Price Risk in Healthcare Claims (Even at the Same Provider)

Tim Michaels
June 9, 2025
3 min Read

The total cost of care (TCOC) is staggeringly variable, even for the exact same treatment, at the same provider. This hidden volatility poses a major risk for stop-loss carriers, MGUs, and self-funded employers managing high-cost claims.

Let’s break it down.

Same Cancer Therapy. Same Hospital. $1.3M Price Gap.

At a major Midwest cancer center, HealthRate analyzed pricing data for Yescarta, a leading CAR-T therapy. Here’s what we found:

  • Lowest contracted rate: $392,410
  • Highest contracted rate: $1,728,291
  • Difference: $1,335,881—for the same treatment, at the same provider.

This pricing spread exists within the same health system, across different network contracts. The lowest prices were often accessible through niche specialty networks—but most plan sponsors and intermediaries don’t have visibility into these rates.

HealthRate Flags Price Outliers Before the Claim Hits Your Books

HealthRate is an innovative insurtech platform designed to bring transparency and clarity to the most complex and costly healthcare claims. Specializing in pricing transparency, HealthRate equips employers, insurers, TPAs, and stop-loss providers with powerful tools to analyze and re-price healthcare cases in real-time.

Use HealthRate to:

  • Benchmark rates in real-time
  • Intervene before payment or care is authorized
  • Optimize network utilization
  • Reduce catastrophic claim payouts

In one case, using HealthRate insights provided a potential plan to refer a patient for the same therapy at the same provider for over $1 million less.

This Isn’t an Exception—It’s the Norm

Every major health system exhibits steep price variability across therapies, surgeries, and chronic care. Chargemaster variability, complex rate structures, siloed contracting, and lack of visibility mean plan sponsors are routinely overpaying—without knowing.

HealthRate surfaces these insights quickly and cleanly—in just minutes—so you can make high-impact decisions that preserve margin and protect your book.

Curious how HealthRate can reduce your largest claim categories? Let’s talk.
Tim Michaels
Insights

Unlocking Insurance Risk Management

Discover valuable insights and tips on managing insurance risks

3 min Read

Don’t Try This at Home: Why DIY Catastrophic Claim Analysis Is Riskier Than You Think

With the rise of healthcare price transparency, open-access data, and AI tools, it’s easy to believe: “We’ve got smart people. We can probably handle this in-house.” We get it. On paper, transplant claims, gene therapies, and bundled pricing don’t look that complicated. But in practice? It’s like watching a YouTube tutorial and deciding to rebuild your transmission. That’s why at HealthRate, we have one simple message for employers, brokers, and TPAs trying to model catastrophic claim risk on their own: “Don’t try this at home.”
3 min Read

The Lottery Paradox: Why Betting Against Rare Healthcare Events Is a Risky Strategy

In philosophy, the Lottery Paradox asks: If you know one ticket will win, but each ticket is unlikely to win, is it rational to believe each ticket will lose? It’s a cautionary tale about how we misjudge low-probability, high-impact events. In healthcare, self-funded employers fall into the same trap every day, especially with organ transplants, gene therapies, and CAR-T treatments. The cost of this thinking? Seven-figure claims that blow past stop-loss.
3 min Read

HealthRate Enhances Transplant Provider Evaluations with Integration of SRTR Quality Data

HealthRate, an award-winning SaaS application specializing in comparing network contracted rates for high-cost medical cases such as transplants, CAR-T, and gene therapy, is proud to announce its integration with the Scientific Registry of Transplant Recipients (SRTR) quality data.

Manage Your Risks Effectively

Try HealthRate today and simplify risk management.